Great News Coming out of boston today. A federal judge in Boston on Tuesday dismissed a lawsuit filed by a group of city taxi owners against the state, rejecting the owners’ claim that a new state law puts them at a competitive disadvantage with ride-hailing services such as Uber and Lyft.
They Proved the Boston Taxi Owners Association did not prove its members were harmed by the law.
“Plaintiffs have not alleged that the Commonwealth has revoked, suspended or impeded its ability to use its [taxi] medallions,” Gorton wrote.
“Their sole claim is that the loss of market exclusivity caused by the enactment of the new . . . statute has diminished the value of their medallions.
“Because plaintiffs have no rights to market exclusivity, they have failed to state a claim upon which relief can be granted.”
The taxi owners had filed the lawsuit in September.
The group had argued in the lawsuit that the so-called Uber legislation, which Governor Charlie Backer signed into law last year, violates its members’ equal-protection rights because it prevents municipalities from regulating ride-hailing companies in the same way they do cabs
The taxi companies said in court filings that they now face an unfair disadvantage in which they must follow strict city rules governing fares, vehicle design, background checks, insurance rates, and more, while drivers for Uber and other transportation network companies — called TNCs in the industry — do not have to follow such strict laws.
“The two industries, taxicab and TNCs, provide similar services, yet with the enactment of the TNC Law are being regulated in an entirely different manner from each other,” the cab owners wrote in their complaint.
But Gorton rejected the association’s arguments.
The dismissal was the second legal setback for the taxi owners in recent weeks. Gorton threw out a related lawsuit in late December that the owners had filed against the City of Boston.
Uber, for Uber Car drivers keep this up and the amount of Yellow Cabs in New York will one day shrink to zero.
For those driving for Uber this is how they still haven't turned a profit. Behind the scenes Uber is staking a claim to a new Taxi World.